Setlist
Whiteboy / UpsideDetails
- Venue: XFM Studios, Manchester, UK
- Date: 7th April 2008
Launch day in-store gig for Hey Ma with crowds queuing up through the night.
So, the day everyone had been waiting for and that many of us never thought we’d ever see. James unleashing another new album and what a corker it has proved to be. Business was brisk at 8 this morning as people queued for the album with the added incentive of wristbands for this intimate gig down in the basement of the flagship HMV store in Manchester.
If the short set is an indicator for the tour, it shows the band in rude health, except Tim still struggling with a back injury, which combined with the cramped stage, didn’t really allow him to dance. Hey Ma is very quickly developing into a singalong anthem, however wrong that might sound given the subject matter. It sounds crisp, fresh and alive. Whiteboy stands comparison with the rest of the album more live than it does on record, Tim’s admonishing ah ah ah ah ah ah ah and wagging finger combined with the cowbell makes it the most fun track in the set. Boom Boom, shorn today of the string-drenched end section, replaced by an extended full-band outro is fierce, the delivery so powerful that the crowd is stunned to silence. I Wanna Go Home starts with some problems with Mark’s programming, which Tim likens to being on a small boat in the fog and sounding like a huge boat is about to hit you. It’s beefier on record and works well on that level, allowing the whole band to show off their range. The best two tracks of the day are saved for last though. Waterfall, the next single, is the highlight. Again, the power in the delivery is captivating in a way James at their very best have no peers at. The set finishes with Upside, once Saul has had a minor altercation over the key (don’t ask me who was right, I wouldn’t have the clue).
And then they’re gone, to a rather embarrassing interview with Channel M, and a signing session.
Full speed ahead for the tour. It’s going to be a good one.
See attached press clippings for more reviews.
Intimate tour warm-up and album preview show.
Following the public pre-recording rehearsals of last September, this low-key return to the band’s new favourite haunt of the Hoxton Bar And Kitchen was the public unveiling of the eleven tracks filtered out from the nineteen that had been previewed in 2007 to make the Hey Ma album, due out next Monday.
It was clear most of the crowd had come to hear what had morphed from those two glorious nights in September, and there were no complaints (apart from the odd dick that couldn’t keep his mouth shut) when the band opened with five tracks from the album – Bubbles, 72, Oh My Heart, Boom Boom and Hey Ma. Bubbles was simply stunning, the band’s ability to take a song and raise it a notch shone through as the song exploded into life half way through. 72 is a more intriguing proposition live than on record, it has a harder edge and a rockier beat and with additional backing vocals, the chorus of “war” is more emphatic. Oh My Heart remains fairly faithful to the album version, which demonstrates that the band appear to have come closer with this record than any before to capturing the excitement and power of their live show on record. Boom Boom benefits from an extended outro which kicks back in after violin and trumpet bring the song down. Hey Ma is singalong, it shouldn’t be despite the subject matter, but people can’t help hollering the chorus back at Tim and clapping their hands in time to Larry’s acoustic.
Moving onto more familiar pastures, the band knock out a spirited version of Destiny Calling with Tim augmenting the lyrics to “come back now we’ve gotten old” and “frame us in your mobile phone”. Fortunately, there’s not too much of the “let’s take some shit pictures on my crappy 2 megapixel phone rather than listening and watching the band” going on tonight. P.S, which Tim says he claimed was written about Patti Smith but really about him, is resurrected and is simply magnificent, with Larry back on slide guitar, Saul making use of his violin (far more frequently tonight than before, which is a good thing) and Andy playing trumpet. A sign of how Laid might have sounded had Andy not departed post-Seven. Another track resurrected from the archives, Junkie, follows on, and whilst it might be seen as putting down the efforts of Michael and Adrian rather than being down to the strength of the rediscovered working relationship, it’s a world apart from the odd showing it received post the release of Pleased To Meet You. Tim and Saul laugh as Tim holds his nose for vocal effect on the first verse.
Semaphore is marked throughout by Larry’s guitar work, particularly in the closing section. It feels a little looser than the album version, and of the new songs, is probably the one that translated least well to the live environment from the album. No such worries for Of Monsters And Heroes And Men. Tim, carrying an injury so he couldn’t dance (not that you can dance to the new material according to Saul’s quip), appears to live and breath every word of this song, based around a poem. It doesn’t build at the end in the way the album version does, but it works extremely well and there’s nothing wrong with changing arrangements and playing songs differently.
Another surprise resurrection into the set is Senorita. Pleased To Meet You has fared quite well in the reunion, somewhat surprisingly given that Larry and Andy didn’t play on it, but perhaps it’s making up for the fact it didn’t really feature at all in the farewell tour in 2001 other than Getting Away With It. Again, the new found harmony and the addition of Larry and Andy, propel the song forward to a new level. More of this resurrection of old material please. Maybe we can even get Millionaires tracks sounding the way they should have sounded.
Waterfall is the highlight of the set hands down. Tim tells us it’s going to be the second single after the one that’s out now. It’s great on record, it’s equally great live, it’s faster, it’s more frenetic, but it keeps to true to the original in its spirit. The intro and outro demonstrate the quality of musicianship in the band. The crowd start to dance. The chatterers shut up.
Waltzing Along comes next and features Andy’s stage debut on guitar. Tim threatens that he’ll be next to do it. I thought he had some nifty work on the e-drums (someone called them that elsewhere so I’m nicking the name) earlier, but I’m not sure a Tom Chaplin style resurrection as an acoustic troubadour would be entirely convincing. Anyway Waltzing Along does what it says on the tin, the crowd continue to dance and sing along.
Whiteboy, the focus track, works so much better live than on record, even though it seems to be played too fast tonight with Tim having to keep up with the speed of the song. Tim teases the audience with a wagging finger during the “ah ah ah ah ah ah ah” section, the song has the “all mashed section” at the start as well. The cheers of recognition mean at least the song has got through to the James myspace generation.
Sometimes is a treat to close the main set. It starts off with just Larry and Tim, accompanied by a room full of singers, before crashing into the second verse with the full band. The end sees Larry continue to play and sing and encourage the crowd to sing louder and louder. It’s fresh, it seemed spontaneous and everyone loved it. And off they went.
I Wanna Go Home started off the encore. It’s a gorgeous number on record, a fitting album closer in the mode of Top Of The World and Alaskan Pipeline. Live it grows and grows and becomes faster and more energetic and frayed at the edges. It just about stops itself from falling over at the end, but there’s still some work to be done on this and it could be the absolute showstopper.
Which brings us on to Upside. Which is full-on seven musicians at the top of their game. The acoustic settings on the verses on the record are ditched in favour of a more direct all-in approach, but still the chorus is the key, the emotion, the heartfelt passion of the subject matter blasts through in a way James’ contemporaries can generally only hope to match. There’s a moment before the song crashes into the final chorus when it stops for what seems like an age before bursting back to life.
Sound closes the set. It doesn’t take on the twelve minute madness of its prior incarnations, but it’s a fitting end to the set, old James at their peak, the centrepiece of the Seven album being played by the original band.
Talking to Saul before the gig, he felt the band had got to a point where they knew the songs well enough to be able to play them without being over-rehearsed and going through the motions. One dark night in Glasgow aside, new James has never been about that. Mark, Jim and Dave haven’t been mentioned before, but they, as ever, hold the songs together, they’re as vital to what is going on up on stage as Tim, Saul, Larry and Andy who play the more showmen role in the band.
Can’t wait for the tour. It’s going to be special. If you haven’t got tickets, beg, steal and borrow.
The second of two shows made up entirely of new songs to roadtest them before the recording sessions for Hey Ma, including some that didn’t make the record. The audience were requested to score and make comments on a pre-printed setlist.
I’m going to try and keep this short and sweet. The new album section of the site will be updated with my notes on each of the songs, assuming I can read my notes of course.
With one listen of all the main set songs behind me, things became quite a lot clearer tonight. Songs fitted themselves into categories quite easily. The ready to record, the jam that needs a bit more. The quiet song, the slow burner, the builder and the all out pop classic. The single, the album track, the b-side.
Child To Burn is a very understated start. It’s gorgeous though with Andy’s whistling through the trumpet and Tim’s very pronounced vocal effects. Good Mood Sunday never quite catches fire. It’s got potential but needs some more work to be the finished article to stand alongside some of the stronger songs tonight. But then, that’s the whole point of the evening anyway, so it’s a bit churlish.
Out Of Our Heads could be the album’s Laid. It’s a bit throwaway, but it’s fun. And just because James are older than most of their peers doesn’t mean they can’t have fun. Other bands should try it. And James are definitely having fun. You can see the glances, the smiles and the focus. Although they did fuck it up the first time. But we can forgive them that.
Tim berates an audience member who seemed to spend most of the gig pogoing for his reaction to Tim mentioning the anniversary of 9/11 before Hey Ma, which has the acoustic intro from Larry still. Waterfall sounds much fresher and crisper than the previous night. Some lovely vocal delivery that builds to a crescendo before going back into the chorus which is followed by some wonderful trumpet over the end section.
I Wanna Go Home is probably my least favourite tonight. It starts off slow and grows with almost chanted lyrics. It does divert off a little towards the end, but not enough for it to stand up fully to some of the more rounded and complete tracks tonight. With the right studio treatment, it’ll probably sound fantastic though.
A/B (renamed 72 when released) and Mother’s A Clown notch the speed up. A/B is very funky and has some wonderful backing vocals from Saul and Larry. Mother’s A Clown is the best representation tonight of the addition of Saul’s violin and Andy’s trumpet into the new songs. Watching the interaction between the plan is a pleasure. They’re enjoying this. They know they can do this. There’s a number of people dancing wildly in the middle. I think it’s alcohol-related but it’s amusing to watch in these circumstances.
Better In Black (renamed to Of Monsters And Heroes And Men when released) starts with a stream of consciousness lyric which sounds like random words, but grows in something quite aching and beautiful. Tim even gets in two different pronunciations of either into one line.
Start A Fire is new. It has promise, but needs another listen to appreciate it fully, I suspect. The muddy sound does make differentiation and subtlety in some of these tempo songs difficult without really intense listening, and it’s hard work.
The set ends with four faster tempo songs which grab back the interest of a few chatterers in the crowd. Oh My Heart is more traditional James although it does have a very surprising false end which almost makes it two songs in one, but Whiteboy starts with Tim banging a cowbell and declaring himself “all mashed up”. The latter definitely has single potential, or focus track potential as our beloved friends in the industry call it.
Bubbles has developed wonderfully since we first heard it in July and demonstrates just how much some of the new songs can build on the very sound foundations to become something truly special.
The last track Boom Boom is a pleasant surprise. Sounding a bit weak on first listen yesterday, it’s now powerful and emotive, driven by the bass with spirals of trumpet cascaded throughout it. It’s really quite wonderful stuff.
They come back tonight for a more familiar encore of Not So Strong and Upside Downside (later renamed to just Upside for the album release). Not So Strong seems a bit ragged. But ragged James brings excitement with it, from chaos comes beauty. I’m not entirely convinced the new lyrics are an improvement on those from the earliest performances, but as it’s work in progress still, I’m sure we’ll end up hearing something quite different next year. Upside doesn’t really need any more praise than it’s had already.
So two rather special nights are over. It’s been hard and intense for the audience, I can’t believe how hard it’s been for the band. But everyone’s smiling, the reaction to the new material is great and it looks like a lot of the relationships have been mended. It reminds me of 1992 and what, for me, was James most fertile and exciting live era. The album is going to sound great, based on what we’ve heard and hopefully it won’t be the last we’ve heard.
Thanks to James for being brave enough to go public with their rehearsals and respect to 99% of the audience who listened and took it in with resorting to loud chatter.
Can’t wait for 2008.
The first of two shows made up entirely of new songs to road-test them before the recording sessions for Hey Ma, including some that didn’t make the record. The audience were requested to score and make comments on a pre-printed setlist. The names of some of the songs changed for the Hey Ma release.
How do you even start to write a review of a gig like this? I don’t think I can recall ever hearing of a band coming on and playing fifteen new songs one after the other, without seemingly pausing for breath. No hits, no hidden classics, hell they don’t even play Upside Downside [ed. later renamed to just Upside for album release], Traffic and Not So Strong, three new songs that thrilled us over the summer. Some of these songs probably won’t make it on the album. Some of them will only probably ever get heard over these two nights. Lyrics will probably change beyond recognition, arrangements will change. With all this going on, you just wonder if the excitement, the newness and the sheer bloody-mindedness of it will drown the event. It is hard work, but it’s the sort of hard work you enjoy. There’s a sense of wonder, a sense of uniqueness, a sense of a future vision of the band. Forget the mega-shows of the big theatres and the arena in April, the hit-laden festival successes of the summer, this is what this reunion is all about.
In order to set the scene, the rather wonderful idea of handing out setlists to everyone was conceived. It is a sign of intent and also a sign that those expecting a concession on hits are wasting their time. It builds the anticipation.
I’m not going trying to do a deep analysis of each of the new songs here – maybe tomorrow night.. I don’t honestly think I could off one listen. The set is a mix of gorgeous slow yearning songs, some poppy upbeat numbers, there’s a number of songs that start off slow and then explode gloriously. Saul plays a lot of violin which adds so much more to the mix than when he plays guitar (not a criticism of his ability on it). Andy’s trumpet is absolutely everywhere and Tim quite often uses that as a cue and also as a board to bounce his vocals off. Larry’s slide guitar permeates the slower songs in a way that made Laid such compelling listening. Mark’s keyboards and Dave’s drums, as ever, hold the whole thing together perfectly. As in all great James songs, the keys are understated. Jim’s bass is the spine for so many of the songs, but, with Larry back, there’s an interplay and a communication there that had gone when Larry departed. Vocally, there’s some interesting vocal styles, particularly on the slower songs. They work well although the muddy sound on the faster songs sometimes distorts them.
Favourite songs at this stage? Child To Burn, A/B, Better In Black and Bubbles. But I’m sure that will be different tomorrow night.
Before playing new song Upside Downside [ed. later renamed to just Upside for album release], Tim dedicated it to Tony Wilson and talked about the spirit and passion that Tony had for music that came from the heart. How ironic that the applause that came back was from the main stage crowd of the most anodyne music festival ever invented (I’ve never been to Stafford, so am basing this off the Chelmsford “experience”).
Glastonbury, Reading and T have their own quirks and charms but they exude a passion for the music and the legacy of the festival experience. They don’t have the complete sanitisation of anything that might make the day a little more interesting. The threat of pulling the plug on the gig if Tim came down to the crowd (who were so far back he could waste a few minutes getting to them) or invited people on stage says everything you need to know. Add to it the people in the front rows who were waiting for The Killers and Kasabian who got upset when people dared to dance near them (I would have loved to seen it when the beered up meatheads appeared as Kasabian came on) and you have the ultimate in watered down emotionless passionless gatherings of people you could imagine. Even Tim’s breast t-shirt was deemed too risque for late night Channel 4 viewing. And the dress provoked some interesting reactions from the hoodies around me until I pointed out a certain Kurt Cobain took great pride at wearing dresses on stage.
A festival with Bacardi tents and The Cider House churning out hours of endless mindless dance “classics” with half the crowd more interested in being seen at the festival because it makes them oh so alternative probably means there’s not a lot of hope for a band like James in that environment. The music demands that you listen to it, it doesn’t just wash over your head, it doesn’t have the easy hooks that The Fratellis and Kasabian who preceded and followed James (and to be fair to both, were reasonably entertaining)..
James response was an uncompromising fuck you approach to the gig. With Tim beset with throat problems, they decided THEY were going to enjoy the set, even if noone else did. And they put on one of the strongest performances of the year. It may have turned a few people, it may have reminded others just how great they are. And Tim’s stroke of genius by ignoring the fascist bully boys and singing the last song Laid from the barrier meant people had something to remember the set by even if many of them hadn’t bothered for the most of it.
Born Of Frustration kicked off the set with Larry’s building brooding intro before crashing into Tim’s trademark yodel. There are pockets of recognition around the crowd, but it’s quite muted. The band don’t seem to care, Andy and Tim prowl the stage, Tim occasionally breaks into dance and the song builds to its epic climax. The sound is dreadful for the first few songs. The opening of Tomorrow is barely audible, but once the guitars are turned up, it’s fast, it’s passionate and yet the crowd are only mildly agitated. It’s not cool to like bands who are as old as your Dad, is it now?
Come Home is the one minor disappointment. For me, it has always sounded best when played fast and hard. The new arrangement has taken some of the edge off it, in my opinion. That said, it probably gets the second best reception of the set. Out To Get You should be a great festival anthem – the swaying masses of arms when it was played at T are testament to this. Here, it’s barely audible because the sound is still so damn poor and people use it as an excuse to chat away and moan when someone dares sing near them. Once the sound gets fixed, the ending goes off on improvised tangents and sounds fantastic.
Getting Away With It doesn’t seem to get much recognition from the crowd, despite the best attempts of the band who play a slightly faster and rockier version than of late. Say Something does at least gets cheers of recognition from parts of the crowd and it’s amusing when Tim starts his improvised end section just as everyone is joining in with the normal words.
Upside Downside doesn’t feel at all out of place in the set. It’d have been nice for James to have taken the really awkward route and played three or four new songs. It’d have been interesting to see the reaction too. But one was probably the wise thing to do, particularly as Upside is the one that’s most ready enough for this size of exposure, brilliant as the other four are. There are a number of arms raised around as the chorus kicks in and it sounds great – not out of place at all amongst the better-known songs in the rest of the set.
Ring The Bells starts the climax towards the end of the set and at last there is some life in the crowd. Tim’s dancing seems to attract the attention of some of the supercool and the hoodies. Tim makes an off the cuff remark that it’s like an intimate pub gig. I think he’s taking the piss.
Following Tim again berating the Gold Mother sees the band invite a number of people on from the side of the stage, including one gentleman waving a homemade James flag and a guy who seems to have boxed himself into some construction involving balloons. Tim wanders off towards the side to sing half the song as the dancers take centre stage. The crowd appear bemused. Noone has done anything today that doesn’t involve standing there and playing the songs. This is something they weren’t expecting. It’s brilliant festival material. Well it would be anywhere else.
The big moment comes as Tim announces they’re going to play the Arctic Monkeys favourite song. I think some of the kids actually believe it too. Larry counts in 1-2-3-4 and Sit Down crashes in. Suddenly there’s more singing along, there’s a bit of a mosh in parts as well. Again, it appears it’s played slightly off speed to put people off the obvious temptation to drown the band out and stretch the song out.
Sometimes seems made for these wider stages. It’s beautifully yearning and the lighting is starting to have an impact as it starts to go dark. The set concludes with Laid. It’s the best performance of the song this year. Tim jumps down off the stage and climbs on the barrier thus committing one of the biggest crimes known to man. To be fair, security do help him until they’re ordered to carry him down at which point Tim runs further down the barrier. The song itself benefits from the extended improvised ending and the bemused reaction on the faces of the crowd.
And then they’re gone. James were great, as they always are in adversity where they always take things on. I’m not sure what came out of the show though. There’s a lot of love and goodwill for James since the reunion and they need to continue to tap into it. T and Belladrum were wonderful experiences with an ecstatic response, and the European festivals appear to have had the same effect. Maybe Tim’s quip that they wouldn’t be allowed back here because he left the stage wouldn’t be a bad thing.
The bald, moustachioed man on the stage wearing the black T-shirt with a pair of breasts printed on it – coupled with a fetching flowing black skirt – is the singer from James. Funnily enough though, for having someone as distinctive looking as Tim Booth, James are musically doing nothing to make themselves stand out. Still, when they play ‘Sit Down’, it all becomes worthwhile, even if we’re not into it enough to give ourselves a muddy bum by joining in.
Upside love you
Downside Miss You
A more appropriate lyric was never written to describe the way I feel writing this review. The love I feel for this band is that unconditional kind of love usually only given by pets and babies. I guess the only difference is that my love includes an overwhelming pride and a protective quality, akin to a lion with her cubs. I even feel that the love is requited. Not on a personal level, that would just be weird, but band to audience. That’s the upside. The downside is that I’m gonna miss them like crazy. Yes, they need to disappear and write an album but these weekly James sojourns have become addictive and habit forming. Not seeing them again for a month or so, I could handle but next year just seems so far away. So, how do they leave me feeling after our final tryst of 2007? Read on if you care.
It’s a bloody miserable day. It rains in a way that suggests that ‘somebody up there’ doesn’t much like music festivals. There is really no need for it, although the rain has caused far more despair in the UK this summer than in my living memory. And I’m not trying to compare a muddy festival to the flooding of peoples homes, I’m not (quite) that crass. However, people look forward to events like this and it is heartbreaking to see such abject despondency. One guy even sells us some beer tokens at a reduced rate because he is “giving it up”. Even Peter Kay walking on the stage to introduce our heroes can’t bring a smile to the faces of the masses. James do though.
The setlist is the one that james have been taking around Europe over the course of the summer. No alarms and no surprises here. They do play Bubbles and Upside Downside [ed. later renamed to just Upside for album release] in the middle of the set, which is a brave move in the early evening slot of a major festival. It is clear that the crowd wants the hits but whilst the new songs are not given the hushed reverence that they were given in Edinburgh, the chattering is kept to a minimum. The band has earned this level of respect due to the opening salvo of monster hits. Born of Frustration throbs and swaggers, Tomorrow soars and Sit Down bounces along in time to the crowd. Or something. Then they play Out To Get You and I look around at thousands of people mouthing the words “Insecure, what you gonna do?” and can barely believe that this was once an obscure b-side, before it’s Laid treatment. It thoroughly deserves it’s place on the Best Of album. Bubbles sounds better with every listen and I have made my feelings on Upside Downside known on many occasions before. Nothing about today’s performance alters my opinion (humble of course) that this could be a hit of epic proportions.
The new songs are followed by another run of james classics and the crowd lap it up. Ring The Bells is greeted like an old friend, Gold Mother sees dancers brought on from backstage because the festival consider the, now customary picking of people from the crowd a “health and safety issue”. Getting Away With It receives a more lukewarm reception than of late. Laid doesn’t. Sometimes is introduced by Tim as the final song and I believe him. Afterall, their allotted time is up. So, will this swirling epic be the final live james song for me this year?. The lyrics certainly hold great resonance today in the pouring rain. However, the festival allow them to run over time and the band choose to close with Come Home, just as they did in Belladrum. Some time after they finish playing, whilst walking in the mud, I decide that this is a far more appropriate way to part from my lover. I just hope that they come home soon.
So there’s no Play Dead or Chain Mail, which the bloody-minded james of yesteryear may have indulged in. Today is a day for giving the people what they want, not a day for blowing a great opportunity. Maybe, just maybe this time the band want it enough to succeed. Tim, Jim, Larry, Saul, Mark, Dave and Andy, you are loved more than you’ll ever know and the upside will always outweigh the downside.
As Tim Booth gazes out over the crowd presently lapping up ‘Sit Down’, his alien eyes take on a wistful, dewy look. He’s missed this, you sense. This is what he lives for, hell, what he was born for.
That’s nice, Tim. We’re happy you and the dream have been reunited, and this state of affairs can probably persist for another few festival seasons. There may yet be enough residual love out there. But only, only, if you play hits and nothing but.
To general head-scratching, James bounce from hit to bellyflop to hit, following ‘Sit Down’ with… something… about eight minutes of violin, flute, Boothy crooning the secrets of the cosmos, and some indistinguishably woozy baggy, yup, something, that hangs in the air like Eau de Shaun Ryder’s Corpse. After ‘Sometimes’, we are coached through their forthcoming single ‘Who Are You’. It’s not a lesson we will forget.
Best Song: ‘Laid’
Best Moment: The way that Boothy’s dancing has lost none of its hippy-dippy tinge. After all these years, he still comes on like a trout attempting semaphore. On drugs. Naturally.
And so onto Belladrum It’s raining. It holds off enough not to be torrential, but those of us down the front had to contend with mud and rain throughout most of the set. From the highs of last night, it was always going to be a bit of a comedown, but following the rather interesting support of a reggae band and then a Johnny Cash tribute band whilst upcoming indie stars Kate Nash, Mumm Ra, Scouting For Girls and Pigeon Detectives and legend Lloyd Cole played sets in tents around the area, James hit the stage just after 9.30.
From the opening bars of Frustration, it was clear that James were going to have the audience eating out of the palms of their hands. Without any insult implied to Michael or Adrian as they brought different things to the James table, the first thirty seconds are pure Larry, the intro building into Tim crashing in with his whooping. The sound is fantastic despite the rain and the band have clearly started off where they left off the previous night. As with last night, Tomorrow and Sit Down follow and are rapturously received and at this point the crowd are eating out of the band’s collective palm. Chain Mail, although over 20 years old, feels perfect for this setting, it broods and grows before the explosion of the chorus.
Similarly, Play Dead doesn’t feel like a previously neglected album track, it holds its right to be in the set as much as anything else, the crowd stand in awe as Larry, Saul and Tim’s accapella ending takes the song to its end. Out To Get You induces much arm-waving and quite oddly some crowd-surfing as people are hauled out from the middle. It stays the right side of cliched though, there are no lighters waved in the air and the improvisation of the ending is there too.
Tim then introduces Bubbles, the first of the two new songs, as a tribute to Tony Wilson. There’s some applause from parts of the crowd who know his legacy, but I suspect it might have been lost on many. The song itself makes much more sense on second listen. It appears to be based on the way human beings are put together, how we become what we are and how our characters are formed. As with many of the new songs, it starts as a slow burner and then flies off in different directions which make it typical James, whilst still maintaining their uniqueness. You’ve read my treatise on Upside Downside [ed. later renamed to just Upside for album release] already. I won’t go into it again, but it was as good as it has been to date. The crowd reaction would support this.
Tim appears to consider coming down to the crowd for Say Something, but takes a look at the mud and the rain and thinks better of it. A wise move probably. Laid followed and was wild. Gold Mother starts with the now traditional inviting of audience members up onto the stage. This does work much better when it is a more random choice of audience members pulled out of the crowd rather than some of the more staged attempts at it (was the girl on stage both nights at Brixton just coincidentally at T In The Park).
Ring The Bells and Sometimes bring the set proper to a frenetic finale, the extended ending of Ring The Bells making the moshpit wilder and larger whilst Sometimes is somewhat appropriate given that the rain has started again by this point. There wasn’t really a lot of point in them leaving the stage before the encore.
The encore opens with She’s A Star and the reworked version is perfect for this, Andy’s input the final missing link from the stripped down version of the April tour. As ever, Getting Away With It gets a fantastic response from the crowd, before a set closing Come Home which is accompanied by a firework display behind the main stage. While you can’t see most of this from our vantage point, I can only imagine it was stunning from up on the banks and hills. And then that was it and we had to face the trawl back through the mud of the car park to the hotel.
So, overall not an anti-climax at all. It’s difficult to reach the intimacy and highs of a small room in a festival setting, even if you are the main attraction, but James don’t disappoint. They gave a taste of the future, but more importantly for next year, they laid down the marker that they’re back, they’re hungrier and they still wipe the floor with mere mortals.
Back in 1998, James took a very young Sophie Ellis-Bextor on tour with her band The Audience. Their standout song (Running Out Of Space) started off with the line “I never thought you’d ever let me down. You’re not the sort, but you’ve got the right to astound.” It’s a line that for me could have been written about James. Last night was one of those nights where James just took off and defied all my expectations, took me out of the physical exhaustion of standing in a scorching room after a day on my feet walking round the hills of Edinburgh, the expectations associated with previous experience of Scottish crowds and the rather dreadful surroundings of the soulless Corn Exchange and the awful sound that had not done the otherwise excellent My Federation support slot any justice at all. I don’t think I stopped dancing the whole set (I am using dancing in the loosest sense of the word here). If this wasn’t the best James gig I’ve seen, it was definitely Top 3.
Coming on stage about ten minutes late, Tim appeared in a skirt (it may have been a kilt, I wasn’t really close enough to tell before I get bombarded by irate Scots calling me a clueless Englishman) and a rather fetching t-shirt with a pair of breasts printed on the front. Quite what the message was, I’m not sure. However, Born of Frustration started with the Larry intro that makes the single version of this song the one you really have to hear (the album and Best Of versions are shorter and miss this out). Immediately the crowd go wild. But not in the way they did in Glasgow, this is a celebratory unison, very little of the testosterone fuelled aggression that plagued the Glasgow gigs in April, but based on the joy music can bring to a room full of people. Andy’s trumpet has added so much to the mix, a very vital element of the live 2007 James sound, bringing back the unscripted more random elements into the mix that made the 1992 live incarnation of the band my favourite period to date. Tomorrow doesn’t let the pace off at all. Fast and frenetic, Tim and Saul are almost nose to nose singing the opening lines and the band take over, driving faster and faster to the climax, the crowd is now a heaving mass of arms and celebratory singalong. Two songs in, I’m hooked and looking around, I think every single person in the room is too.
Next comes the song to furl all the James debates. For me, and this comes after years of maybe sitting the other side of the fence, Sit Down has to be played. It is the song that everyone knows and when you take away the excessive radio play and the “I know that song ‘oh sit down'” debates of the past fifteen years, and in this environment standing in a room full of 2,000 people when they realise what Larry’s 1-2-3-4 is leading into is, for me who isn’t really into that thing, an almost revelatory experience. Stripping it to base facts, it’s a fucking amazing amazing song and without it, we wouldn’t be watching James here today. In true awkward fashion, you suspect it’s played at a slightly different pace and the opportunity to develop it into a singalong is denied. But it just makes it all the more powerful by doing so.
Chain Mail starts up. And it’s clear that many don’t know it. But what they do is carry on dancing or they stand and listen. They don’t start chattering or shouting loudly. They listen. The song grows menacingly as Tim and Andy prowl the stage, building to the final chorus which crashes in as the room explodes into a blaze of light. Play Dead follows and again the crowd react the same and by the end I think most people are dancing or standing open-mouthed and staring at what they’re witnessing.
Out To Get You induces the traditional waving of arms and communal singing and grows to a wild improvised ending with Tim stage left, dancing wildly encouraging Jim and Saul onwards as they stand face to face pushing each other further and further.
Tim introduces the first of two new songs getting their first play Bubbles with the sad news that Tony Wilson, founder of Factory Records, long-time supporter of James and Manchester legend, had passed away earlier in the evening. I’m sure there will be hundreds of epitaths for this great man, but dedicating a brand new song to him was somehow appropriate. Tony supported James throughout their career even though they walked away from Factory very early in their careers and he and James shared a rather unique and successful approach to what they do. It was self-evident there was a lot of love between the band and the man.
The song itself is clearly works in progress. The beginning gives this away, but it grows rather splendidly by the mid section and the chorus has grabbed me by the end of the song. It takes a lot of balls with what’s gone before to risk totally killing the atmosphere that has been built up with a run of new songs, but the crowd appear to love it.
The more familiar, but still brand new to most, Not So Strong follows. Again, works in progress, but far more roundly formed already than its predecessor. It’s a great, great song, but is still changing and evolving. Tim has written some new verses since the last UK performance at Oran Mor, and to be honest, they take a bit of getting used to especially as, in my opinion, the old ones were perfectly fine as they were. But part of this set of shows is to roadtest these songs before going into the studio next month.
The third of the medley of new songs is introduced as being about September 11 and its consequences and it’s another first play. The title doesn’t get revealed so we’ll call it Hey Ma as the main chorus line appears to be “Hey Ma, your son’s coming home in a bodybag.” This one appears further progressed than Bubbles and it gets the best crowd reaction of the three new songs. Now we’ve heard what it is probably the basis of half of next year’s album and it’s looking very good so far.
Conscious of the fact they might have killed the atmosphere that had built up (they hadn’t although Tim asking if people wanted another new one before Hey Mom and admitting he sympathised with the “no” answers meant they thought this could have happened) they launched into Say Something. Whether Tim coming down and standing on the barrier wearing a kilt was a wise idea, I’m not sure, but he took to banging people on the head with his microphone who tried to find the answer to the age-old question. The crowd were back into heaving mass mode and from looking at those around me, the joy on the faces and the dancing told you everything about the power and passion that was being generated on stage.
Even Laid, which for me has been the one song that I’d come to the conclusion I wouldn’t miss if they didn’t play it again, is absolutely mental. Total strangers are hollering the song to each other around me and all the way back to the sounddesk is a mass of bodies and arms.
For Gold Mother, Tim and Saul select audience members to join them on stage and dance with them. The song itself is wild. It veers wildly as it moves from section to section, the lights adding more and more to the impact as the song grows and builds with Tim stage right, megaphone inches from Larry’s face, pushing and encouraging him on. The rest of the crowd keep the dancing going or stand in awe at what they’re witnessing.
Ring The Bells and Sometimes bring the set to a close. The extended ending of Ring The Bells with Andy chanting “shoot the fucker” as Tim loses himself in dance and the band ratch the noise up louder and faster. At the end the crowd go mental as the band stand and stare and applaud. It’s been some experience so far, a demonstration of the power of music in the live environment and a band that has hopefully cast off the internal fighting that blighted a lot of the last ten years of their first coming (or second or third or fourth or fifth depending on how you view their history). No other band I have ever seen can live with James when they are on this kind of form.
The encore starts with the song that could hopefully relaunch James into the public consciousness. An unashamed over the top love song about being separated from a loved one, Upside Downside [ed. later renamed to just Upside for album release] has almost everything you could want in a song. It’s brimming with emotion and passion from the lyrics and also the music which matches what is being expressed in the words. I don’t think I can express how great this song is in mere words, so I’ll move on.
Getting Away With It belies its in at 22 and gone the next week status and is sung back with as much enthusiasm by the crowd as anything that has gone before it. Tim strikes and holds the John Travolta pose as the lights flash around him.
The set closes with She’s A Star. I was sceptical of the new arrangement on first hearing, but it’s been beefed up and works perfectly. Larry’s guitar pervades throughout the song and carries the fragility of the new version. The crowd, as they have most of the night, sing along word perfect. And then they’re gone.
It’s now ten the next morning. After a wander round Asda, an hour’s drive to Perth, some southern comfort and cherry coke (not my idea and it doesn’t really work) and a few hours sleep, I’m still buzzing from the adrenalin of the gig. It’s a massive contrast to the feeling at eight last night when I volunteered I might have been happier in a field a hundred and fifty miles north chilling out watching The Magic Numbers than in a hot sweaty room with awful sound and feet throbbing from all the walking I’d done. But that’s what James can do. They very rarely, if ever, let you down, but every so often, they produce a gig that blows away anything you’ve seen for a while. Last night was one of those nights. I can only hope tonight isn’t one big comedown.